Letter in the Annandale Advocate, April 8, 2008 - with their permission:

LETTER: Member says its worth saving

Laura Hood Beckman, Annandale

Apr 8, 2008


I am reminded every day why the Annandale area is such a wonderful place to live and raise a family. This community is rich in volunteerism, willing citizens that work hard to make this a great place to live, learn and grow. I was honored to be asked to serve on the school district's 2007 Facilities Task Force. I know there were many people willing to sit on this group and so feel fortunate that I was asked. Myself and a dozen other area citizens, school district teachers and administrators including two school board members spent the last six months reviewing a lot of information. I learned many things about our school facilities, what constitutes good learning space, what are ideal school sizes to provide maximum successful learning and recommended standards from our State Department of Education. Our group had the opportunity to review information from Wold Architects regarding building needs, costs and a few potential design scenarios. Our job was to review the work of the last Facilities Task Force to determine if their findings were current for today. A number of things had changed including concerns with the 1922 building, which is the three-story structure that is currently being used as part of our middle school. As someone that believes in recycling and great architectural design, I was thrilled to find out first and foremost that it is possible to renovate the building so that it can continue to be used for academic purposes. We had been told at the start of our meetings and prior that the building had so many fire and building code violations that it could not be repaired. However, when a building inspector and representative of the State Fire Marshal toured the facility last fall both indicated that many needed maintenance items could be addressed without having to upgrade to some of the current new construction requirements. Touring the building, we had the opportunity to see the spacious classrooms, fantastic natural lighting and architectural detailing that we could never afford to duplicate today in a new building. Although neglected, this building today is still within reason to renovate and continue to serve our community another 80 years. We also discussed the possibility of having a private party purchase the 1922 building. Unfortunately the legalities of having a private party utilize a building that is attached to a functioning school is not likely. Another issue that was raised was the land size of the middle school site. In today's standards it is small, however, like many schools in small towns and urban areas the school continues to function well. All schools in our district are landlocked; and that happens eventually with any new site construction. The group was varied in opinions and priorities with not only the 1922 building but also other school district needs. There are many ways to achieve the same goal, that being great learning facilities for our students and teachers. I commend all that spent time on this effort and gave of their time and viewpoints. At some point the group needed to close. Over the course of the six months we reviewed a variety of scenarios with many other variations not explored, however the group could not go on forever. At what ended up to be our last meeting we were provided a new proposal draft that included adopting a long-range plan to begin to abandon the current middle school site by demolishing the 1922 building. The majority of the group approved this recommendation that will be presented to the school board on April 28. One of my concerns with this plan is that it commits taxpayers to purchasing land and building a new middle school in the future. The location would be farther out of the heart of town. Many people find the location of the middle school ideal as the children can walk to the public library or downtown to have something to eat after school or an activity. It is a convenient location for parents as well as they are able to run errands downtown while they wait for their children. Many of the churches are within a reasonable and safe walking distance for many kids that have church school on Wednesdays. The school's present location is very favorable with current community design trends that promote safety, walkability, health and a sense of neighborhood. The cost to build the 1922 building was $140,000. Over 84 years that is $1,666 per year. With the proper repair and maintenance we can enjoy another 84 years. I hope our other facilities can provide that type of return on our taxpayer investment. As a task force we were only a small group of people, recognizing there are many citizens with ideas, concerns and opinions. It will be up to the school board to decide how to best move forward. I sincerely hope the school board members decide to keep the middle school in its current location.